Search
Horse Thief Fishing Reports
Change View:
By: Honk
Posted: 5/20/2018
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 4
Fished: 5/19/2018
Hot Spots: 0
Went fishing for some trout with my brother and his wife. Got there around noon. Started catching fish around a half hour later. Landed 11 trout and one bass between us. Quit about six pm.
By: fisherman92
Posted: 5/23/2017
Species: Smallmouth Bass
Rating: 5
Fished: 5/19/2017
Hot Spots: 0
Went to hortheif lake the morning of the 19th. Afternoon of the 20th and morning of the 22nd. Best day by far was the first day early about 6am and done by 10am or so. Fished the train damn for a bit ...
By: bigdaddyj73
Posted: 6/8/2015
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 1
Fished: 5/23/2015
Hot Spots: 0
Bank fished on the west side by the penninsula. There was a couple nibbles, but that is it. I switched from worms to Powerbait to eggs to lures. Only thing that even got a nibble was green glittery...
By: mrem27
Posted: 5/10/2012
Species: Largemouth Bass
Rating: 5
Fished: 5/7/2012
Hot Spots: 0
So... not so much a 5 star day in terms of keepers but.... did catch the first fish of the season a monster 6 inch smallmouth on a 3 inch weighted tube... than proceeded to catch his four twin brother...
By: fishinChristian
Posted: 6/5/2011
Species: Largemouth Bass
Rating: 5
Fished: 6/5/2011
Hot Spots: 0
Portland trip from Yakima had to be, so I took the pontoon and stopped at Horsethief. Pretty good day, weather perfect for this lake.
14 Largemouth from 8" to 6.75 lbs, 1 tiny walleye (11"), 7 sma...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 7/19/2009
Species: Smallmouth Bass
Rating: 4
Fished: 7/16/2009
Hot Spots: 0
My wife,son and grandson camped at horsetheif lake.and boy did we have a great time all but the wind was crazy,We cought many many bass.It was my wifes first time after bass as she likes trout but i t...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 9/2/2008
Species: Smallmouth Bass
Rating: 5
Fished: 8/22/2008
Hot Spots: 0
Had a great day with my son and grandson, we had lots of action, lots of fish and released most of them.Most were on plastics in about three to five feet of water,we were the only ones on the lake
By: Anonymous
Posted: 6/25/2006
Species:
Rating: 1
Fished: 6/25/2006
Hot Spots: 0
Must have a float or a boat for this lake and look out for the beavers in this pond. It was nasty. You couldnt even cast far enough from shore. Lots and I mean lots of weeds. Needs to be cleaned o...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 4/25/2003
Species:
Rating: 3
Fished: 4/25/2003
Hot Spots: 0
I broke my standing rule and fished opening weekend. Not many people at Horsethief, maybe 10 boats at the most and only 10 - 12 people on the shore. Fishing from the bank was slow to none. Out on t...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 4/6/1998
Species:
Rating: 5
Fished: 4/6/1998
Hot Spots: 0
It was great. we caught 10 to 15 smallmout bass in about an hour. We
were using a special tecnique. We had the whole lake to our self. it was
a great day. Our technique was purple lizards tipped wit...